# 4140 heat treatment: hardening, tempering and annealing

Short answer: To heat treat 4140, austenitize at about 845–860 °C (1550–1575 °F), quench in oil and temper at once. Tempering at about 205 °C (400 °F) leaves roughly 51–55 HRC; about 595–650 °C (1100–1200 °F) gives roughly 24–33 HRC. Anneal at about 845 °C (1550 °F) with a slow furnace cool. Values are typical; follow the supplier's data.

## Key takeaways

- Harden 4140 at about 845–860 °C (1550–1575 °F) and quench in oil, not water.
- Tempering temperature sets final hardness: roughly 51–55 HRC at 205 °C, roughly 24–29 HRC at 650 °C (approximate).
- Avoid tempering at about 250–400 °C (480–750 °F) where toughness matters.
- Pre-hardened 4140 is typically 28–32 HRC and needs no further heat treatment.
- Welding 4140 needs preheat, typically about 200–315 °C (400–600 °F), low-hydrogen filler and post-weld stress relief.

## 4140 heat treatment at a glance

4140 heat treatment follows a standard quench-and-temper route: austenitize at about 845–860 °C (1550–1575 °F), quench in oil, then temper between about 205 and 650 °C (400–1200 °F) to set the final hardness, from roughly the low 50s HRC down to the mid 20s HRC. Annealing at about 845 °C (1550 °F) with a slow furnace cool gives the soft, machinable condition.

[4140](https://machinistcharts.com/material/4140-steel/) is a chromium-molybdenum alloy steel with 0.38–0.43 % carbon, 0.80–1.10 % chromium and 0.15–0.25 % molybdenum. The alloying gives it enough hardenability to harden through moderate sections in oil, which is why it is the default heat-treatable shaft and fixture steel. Its nearest equivalents are EN 1.7225 (42CrMo4), JIS SCM440 and China GB 42CrMo.

| Process | Typical temperature | Cooling | Purpose and result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annealing | about 845 °C (1550 °F) | Slow furnace cool | Softest condition for machining, typically about 197 HB |
| Normalizing | about 870 °C (1600 °F) | Still air | Refines grain and evens out forged or rolled structure; harder than annealed |
| Hardening | about 845–860 °C (1550–1575 °F) | Oil quench | Forms martensite; typically mid to high 50s HRC as quenched in small sections |
| Tempering | about 205–650 °C (400–1200 °F) | Air | Trades hardness for toughness; sets final hardness |
| Stress relieving | below the last tempering temperature | Slow or air cool | Removes machining or welding stress without changing hardness much |
| Nitriding | about 500–550 °C (930–1020 °F) | In furnace | Hard, wear-resistant surface on a quenched and tempered core |

> All temperatures and hardness values on this page are typical. Follow the steel supplier's heat-treat data and the heat treater's procedure for your section size; the governing standard and mill certificate decide the grade and its properties.

## Annealing and normalizing 4140

Anneal 4140 at about 845 °C (1550 °F), hold until it is heated through, then cool slowly in the furnace. Normalize at about 870 °C (1600 °F) and cool in still air.

Annealed 4140 is the softest condition and machines best. Typical annealed properties are about 197 HB, a yield strength of about 415 MPa (60 ksi) and a tensile strength of about 655 MPa (95 ksi). Most 4140 bar bought "annealed" arrives in this condition from the mill.

Normalizing is used after forging or on unevenly worked material, and before hardening, to give a uniform, fine-grained starting structure. Normalized 4140 is harder and stronger than annealed and is less pleasant to machine. A normalize before hardening reduces distortion and gives a more even response to the quench.

## Hardening 4140 steel

Harden 4140 by heating to about 845–860 °C (1550–1575 °F), soaking until the section is uniformly at temperature, and quenching in oil. Small sections reach typically mid to high 50s HRC as quenched.

1. **Protect the surface.** Use a protective atmosphere, vacuum, salt bath or stainless foil wrap, or leave grinding stock. Decarburized skin stays soft and reads low on a hardness test.

2. **Heat evenly.** Bring the part up uniformly; preheat large or complex parts to reduce distortion.

3. **Soak.** Hold at the austenitizing temperature until the core is at temperature. A common rule of thumb is about 1 hour per 25 mm (1 in) of section; the supplier or heat treater sets the actual time.

4. **Quench in oil.** Use agitated quench oil. A water quench is more severe and risks cracking on 4140, especially at sharp corners, holes and section changes. Polymer quenchants are used where the heat treater has a proven procedure.

5. **Temper at once.** Temper when the part has cooled to about 50–65 °C (120–150 °F), hand warm. Untempered martensite is brittle and can crack if left overnight.

Section size matters. 4140 through-hardens well in moderate sections, but in large diameters the core cools too slowly to become fully martensitic and ends up softer than the surface. For heavy sections that must harden through, 4340 is the usual step up.

## 4140 heat treat chart: hardness vs tempering temperature

Tempering sets the final hardness of 4140: higher temperature gives lower hardness and higher toughness. The 4140 heat treat chart below shows approximate hardness after an oil quench and tempering, for small, fully hardened sections.

| Tempering temperature | Approx. hardness, HRC | Note |
|---|---|---|
| 205 °C (400 °F) | 51–55 | Low temper: high hardness, low toughness |
| 260 °C (500 °F) | 49–53 | Avoid where toughness matters (tempered martensite embrittlement range) |
| 315 °C (600 °F) | 47–51 | Avoid where toughness matters (tempered martensite embrittlement range) |
| 370 °C (700 °F) | 45–49 | Avoid where toughness matters (tempered martensite embrittlement range) |
| 425 °C (800 °F) | 42–46 |  |
| 480 °C (900 °F) | 38–42 |  |
| 540 °C (1000 °F) | 33–38 |  |
| 595 °C (1100 °F) | 29–33 | Range used for pre-hardened bar and tough shafts |
| 650 °C (1200 °F) | 24–29 | Range used for pre-hardened bar and tough shafts |

These are approximate values and are section-size dependent. Thicker parts, a slower quench or a leaner heat of steel give lower hardness at the same tempering temperature. Use the chart to choose a starting temperature, then confirm on the part or a test piece with a hardness tester. For HRC to Brinell and tensile conversions, see the [steel hardness chart](https://machinistcharts.com/guides/steel-hardness-chart/).

Temper for at least 1–2 hours at temperature, longer for thick sections, then cool in air. A second temper is sometimes used on critical parts to even out hardness and relieve quench stress.

### Temper embrittlement: temperatures to avoid

Tempering 4140 in roughly 250–400 °C (480–750 °F) can lower impact toughness even though hardness looks normal. This is called tempered martensite embrittlement. Where toughness matters, such as shafts, studs and parts that see shock, temper below or above this range instead.

A second, separate effect called temper embrittlement can occur when 4140 is held in, or slowly cooled through, roughly 375–575 °C (700–1070 °F). It depends on trace impurities in the steel. For critical parts tempered above this range, cool reasonably quickly after tempering and follow the heat treater's procedure. Neither effect shows up on a hardness test; only an impact test reveals it.

## Pre-hardened 4140 (4140 HT / PH)

Pre-hardened 4140, sold as 4140 HT, 4140 PH or quenched-and-tempered 4140, is hardened and tempered at the mill to typically 28–32 HRC, about 271–301 HB. It is machined in that condition and used without further heat treatment.

Pre-hardened bar saves a heat-treatment step and removes the risk of distortion after machining. It machines well with carbide at reduced speed compared with annealed bar; drilling and tapping need sharp tools and rigid setups. Check the [tap drill chart](https://machinistcharts.com/tap-drill/) and [drill bits for metal](https://machinistcharts.com/guides/drill-bits-for-metal/) before drilling it. Suppliers also offer other hardness ranges, so the order and certificate state the actual range.

Do not heat pre-hardened 4140 above the temperature it was tempered at, for example when stress relieving, welding or nitriding, or the hardness will drop. Ask the supplier for the tempering temperature if it matters.

## Stress relieving and nitriding 4140

Stress relieve unhardened 4140 at about 550–650 °C (1020–1200 °F). Stress relieve hardened or pre-hardened 4140 at least about 25–50 °C (45–90 °F) below its last tempering temperature, so the hardness does not fall.

Stress relieving between rough and finish machining reduces movement on long shafts and parts with heavy stock removal on one side. Hold until heated through and cool slowly.

4140 nitrides well. Gas nitriding is typically done at about 500–550 °C (930–1020 °F) over a long cycle, often tens of hours. The part is hardened and tempered first, at a tempering temperature above the nitriding temperature, so the core keeps its hardness. Nitriding gives a hard, wear-resistant surface with very little distortion and no quench, which suits pre-hardened 4140 spindles, tool holders and gears. Case depth and hardness depend on the process; the nitrider quotes them. Induction and flame hardening are other ways to harden only the surface of 4140.

## 4140 vs 4340 steel

4340 is 4140 with about 1.65–2.00 % nickel added. It hardens deeper and is tougher at the same hardness, so it is used for heavy sections and highly loaded parts; 4140 is cheaper and is enough for most shafts and fixtures.

| Point | 4140 | 4340 |
|---|---|---|
| Carbon, % | 0.38–0.43 | 0.38–0.43 |
| Nickel, % | none specified | 1.65–2.00 |
| Chromium, % | 0.80–1.10 | 0.70–0.90 |
| Molybdenum, % | 0.15–0.25 | 0.20–0.30 |
| Hardenability | Good, moderate sections | Higher, heavy sections |
| Toughness at same hardness | Good | Higher |
| Cost | Lower | Higher |
| Typical parts | Shafts, spindles, tool holders, studs, gears | Heavy shafts, crankshafts, landing gear, highly stressed parts |

Both are heat treated in a similar way: oil quench and temper. For a lower-cost, surface-hardened alternative, see [1045](https://machinistcharts.com/material/1045-steel/); for the more weldable chromoly grade, see [4130](https://machinistcharts.com/material/4130-steel/). The wider family is explained in [carbon steel grades](https://machinistcharts.com/guides/carbon-steel-grades/).

## Welding 4140: preheat and post-weld heat treatment

4140 can be welded but needs preheat, low-hydrogen filler and slow cooling, because its carbon and alloy content form hard, crack-prone martensite in the heat-affected zone. Typical preheat is about 200–315 °C (400–600 °F), higher for thick or hardened sections.

- Preheat the joint area through its thickness and hold at least the preheat temperature between passes.

- Use low-hydrogen electrodes or wire, stored dry. Hydrogen is the main cause of delayed cracking in 4140 welds.

- Cool slowly after welding, for example under insulating blanket.

- Stress relieve or temper after welding. On hardened or pre-hardened 4140, keep the post-weld heat treatment below the original tempering temperature.

Where a weld must be strong and crack-free, use a qualified welding procedure. If the part can be redesigned, bolting it often avoids the problem: see the [bolt torque chart](https://machinistcharts.com/bolt-torque/) and [bolt grades and markings](https://machinistcharts.com/guides/bolt-grades-and-markings/). For other grades, see [tool steel grades](https://machinistcharts.com/guides/tool-steel-grades/) and the [steel equivalents](https://machinistcharts.com/material/) list.

## Common questions

### What temperature do you harden 4140 steel?

4140 is typically hardened by austenitizing at about 845–860 °C (1550–1575 °F), soaking until the section is at temperature, and quenching in oil. Small sections reach the mid to high 50s HRC as quenched. Temper immediately afterwards. Follow the steel supplier's heat-treat data for the exact temperature and soak time for your section.

### What hardness is 4140 after tempering?

After an oil quench, 4140 tempered at about 205 °C (400 °F) is roughly 51–55 HRC, at 425 °C (800 °F) roughly 42–46 HRC, at 540 °C (1000 °F) roughly 33–38 HRC and at 650 °C (1200 °F) roughly 24–29 HRC. These are approximate values for small sections; larger sections come out softer.

### What is the annealing temperature for 4140?

4140 is typically annealed at about 845 °C (1550 °F), held until heated through and cooled slowly in the furnace. Annealed 4140 is typically about 197 HB with a yield strength of about 415 MPa (60 ksi) and tensile strength of about 655 MPa (95 ksi). Normalizing is done at about 870 °C (1600 °F) with an air cool.

### What is pre-hardened 4140?

Pre-hardened 4140, sold as 4140 HT or 4140 PH, is quenched and tempered at the mill to typically 28–32 HRC, about 271–301 HB. It is machined in that condition and used without further heat treatment, avoiding distortion after machining. Do not heat it above its original tempering temperature or it will soften.

### Can you water quench 4140?

Water quenching 4140 is not recommended. 4140 has enough hardenability to harden in oil, and the much more severe water quench raises the risk of cracking and distortion, especially at sharp corners, holes and changes in section. Use agitated oil or a polymer quenchant with a proven procedure from the heat treater.

### What is the difference between 4140 and 4340?

4340 has the same 0.38–0.43 % carbon as 4140 but adds 1.65–2.00 % nickel. The nickel gives deeper hardening and higher toughness at the same hardness, so 4340 is used for heavy sections and highly stressed parts such as crankshafts and landing gear. 4140 costs less and suits most shafts, spindles and fixtures.

### What preheat is needed to weld 4140?

Welding 4140 typically needs a preheat of about 200–315 °C (400–600 °F), higher for thick or hardened parts, held between passes. Use low-hydrogen filler, cool slowly and stress relieve or temper after welding, staying below the original tempering temperature on hardened stock. A qualified welding procedure governs critical welds.

Source page: https://machinistcharts.com/guides/heat-treating-4140-steel/
Updated: 2026-10-24
Publisher: MachinistCharts (https://machinistcharts.com)
